Sunday, 14 September 2008

PAD protest: Forgetful Kelly

Kelly
I have resisted writing about this Australian woman for ages. Kelly Newton Wordsworth - her name alone is a mouthful - sings folk songs at the People's Alliance for Democracy rally in Bangkok.

For those unfamiliar with the PAD, let me decode some of the above. For "rally," what I really mean is "illegal occupation of Government House".

For "democracy", I should say that in fact, PAD proposes moving away from the hard won, one-man, one vote version of democracy we have now, in favour of a regime where 70% of politicians would be appointed.

Kelly, who hails from West Australia, is a darling of the PAD. Some gullible Thais believe if a farang supports their cause, it helps lend it credibility. We are just mere Thais, they seem to think - but here's a farang, and even she agrees with us!

That's sad, of course. Even sadder is that people like Kelly know that, and exploit it.

I wonder what Kelly would think if a Thai person showed up in her land and started advocating noisily that Australians should scrap democracy in favour of a system where a group of wise men (in Thailand, they would all be men - sorry, Kelly) get to choose who represents voters.

I suspect she would not like it. I don't think any Australian would like it.

Why should Thais want, or deserve anything less? If Kelly can't answer that question, then she would be well advised to steer clear of Thai politics.

Her website calls Kelly an "internationally renown [sic] singer/songwriter, performer and recording artist". Kelly, who has been playing at PAD protest rallies for a year, is perhaps best known for a song she wrote called the King of Siam.

Ever since I saw the face of this man,

The king of Thailand, The king of Siam

I felt in love with his soul loves this land

It's in his eye, it's in his heart, it's in his hand...

Since then she has written two more songs, Rain Man, and her latest effort, For the People at the PAD, in which she says explicitly that the PAD are protesting for democracy.

Well, if that's democracy, Kelly, what do you have at home?

Here, thousands of people hit the streets as recently as the early 1990s in their fight for it. Some were shot in the process. I suspect Australians like Kelly have had it too good for too long, or they might remember what their own struggle was like.

You can read more about Forgetful Kelly in this piece from the Manager newspaper online (Thai only), which is owned by a PAD co-founder, Sondhi Limthongkul. It has run so many stories about her that I have lost count.

At work, we often have the television going. I have watched Kelly - who describes herself as a "humanitarian" - performing on the PAD stage, in broadcasts run by a television channel also owned by Sondhi. Her songs go on, and on...and on.

Thais in the crowd applaud. But the farang at my office grit their teeth.

Give a girl a translator, and there's no stopping her. When Kelly realises that a Thai on the PAD stage is prepared to translate into Thai her toe-licking utterances in English, she won't shut up. In the clip, she performs with her daughter Tara. "This, my daughter Tara," she says.

Where's the "is" in that sentence? Kelly is afraid Thais won't get it, so she leaves it out.

Freedom-fighter Kelly has also written a song to honour Nelson Mandela. I wonder how Nelson would feel about an electoral system stacked with 70% of appointed flunkies?

I doubt he would call it democracy...unless blacks, too, are unworthy of one man, one vote. What do you say, Kelly?

3 comments:

  1. 12 comments:

    mantrix14 September 2008 at 21:32
    I'm Australian, and support the democratic election of a government.. not what PAD is advocating.
    As for this Kelly woman, I have never heard of her. You say 'world re-knowned'? Hmm maybe in her own lunch break. She is a nobody here.

    Chris

    ReplyDelete

    Nut14 September 2008 at 21:39
    What the hell? What does she know about Thai politics? This is utter nonsense. The more I read about PAD in your blog, the more I think their version of democracy is messed up.

    ReplyDelete

    Anonymous14 September 2008 at 22:48
    I'm also Australian and agree wih mantrix. She's (Kelly whoever) is an idiot jumping onto a bandwagon she knows nothing about.I've lived in Thailand for a while and I think PAD are a bunch of feudal reactionaries.

    ReplyDelete

    Anonymous16 September 2008 at 02:11
    I have seen this woman on TV singing that song and it's freaky!! Who is she and why is she doing this! It makes me embarrassed as an Australian!

    ReplyDelete

    Anonymous22 September 2008 at 07:41
    Hi Guys, thank you for telling me you are Australians, from Australia (Known as Aussies - hehehe) and showing your knowledge and opinion about the democratic in Thailand.

    Have you guy understand the word "DEMOCRATIC"???

    Democratic means only Election????, Democratic means Australian???


    I am Thai and I am Australian too (Duo passports). I have been living in Australian for more than 10 years. I have voted for the Australian PM, Australian local government and recently voted for the city council. I think, I understand the Australian and Thai democratic more than you guys.

    I have read the Thai’s Democtatic article in the Newspapers and the Internet. I have seen Kelly Newton on the TV too.

    I think, she does the right things and that is her opinion. If you guys don’t like just shut up.

    ReplyDelete

    ReplyDelete
  2. Anonymous28 September 2008 at 10:19
    If you are getting this info from Thai Media, you need to realize that most Thai Media is heavily supported by the

    government - so yes, it IS heavily censored and you're only getting half, beit highly-biased story.
    What you're not hearing is that the dark-skinned ppl who are very poor, are also very uneducated and so very prone

    to vote-buying, and "paying off". It makes sense cause they need to put food on the table (yes, they are THAT

    poor).
    If everyone was educated, they would know the best interest for Thailand is to remove the very corrupt government

    that rides on the poor (by putting them in greater debt for each day's food and excessive spending) to reward the

    rich (freedom of exploitation for the poor). Now tell me, does that sound like a sustainable government platform

    for Thailand?

    ReplyDelete

    Anonymous15 October 2008 at 09:39
    Speaking of Democracy and freedom.. uh, I notice my comment has been deleted and censored.

    Well done, hypocrite.

    ReplyDelete

    Bkkdreamer15 October 2008 at 17:11
    Deleted and censored? Goodness me. Just one would do the trick, I think.

    Your comment was deleted because it was offensive. Try again, idiot - this time without the swear words.

    If you can't manage that much, then don't bother.

    ReplyDelete

    Anonymous8 August 2009 at 11:20
    Couple of freaks!

    ReplyDelete

    Anonymous22 October 2009 at 06:12
    I am an Australian, and have been following Kelly's work for a while. Kelly has been a committed humanitarian and environmental activist for years. A LONG time before the PAD existed.

    She has made a massive difference to our country. Her work helped to save over 1.5 million hectares of old growth forest in Australia, she's been singing for peace in countries all over the world! She hasn't jumped on some bandwagon, she has been working to make a better and safer world for a long time, way before it was 'cool' or there was any bandwagon to jump on.

    Don't you think you should do some research on a person before you write ungracious and cruel lies about them? I suggest that you have a look at the amount she has achieved in her life, maybe you will feel differently.

    ReplyDelete

    Anonymous20 June 2010 at 21:28
    " I have seen this woman on TV singing that song and it's freaky!! Who is she and why is she doing this! It makes me embarrassed as an Australian!"

    Totally agree. This woman is a mental case with absolutely no idea about Thai politics. She needs to get lost before someone kills her.

    What a joke.

    ReplyDelete

    ReplyDelete
  3. Bkkdreamer27 June 2010 at 09:11
    If we don't like it, just shut up?

    Australians might be entitled to think that as a Thai, your understanding of democracy is relatively under-developed, as you have so little exoperience of it.

    But they give you the benefit of the doubt nonetheless. They grant you citizenship, the right to own property, and vote.

    Foreigners in Thailand get no such right to vote, no matter how long they live here. Their right to own property is limited. Citizenship can be bought, at a steep price.

    No doubt foreigners don't deserve it - they don't know democracy as well as you Thais do.

    If you a PAD supporter, you would deprive your own countrymen of the right to one man, one vote.

    You say democracy is about more than voting. But by your own account, you have eagerly embraced the right to vote in Australia, and would not give it up in a huurry.

    So what about your fellow Thais?

    ReplyDelete

    ReplyDelete

Comments are welcome, in English or Thai (I can't read anything else). Anonymous posting is discouraged, unless you'd like to give yourself a name at the bottom of your post, so we can tell who you are.